Trader Joe’s is hit or miss when it comes to new products. Frozen Spicy Spuds? Major hit. French-style ham and cheese sandwich? Airport food-level fail. But that’s kind of the fun. They aren’t afraid to try something new—regardless of the reviews. Worst case scenario? They take it off the shelves never to return.

But sometimes Trader Joe’s releases a new product that divides its fans. Such is the case with the new Earl Grey Blondies. The limited-time blondies are flavored with real black tea leaves and topped with crystal sugar. And they’re getting extremely mixed reviews.

Most of the dissenters complain that the Earl Grey flavor isn’t strong enough. Some take umbrage with the texture. And some (unfavorably) compare the flavor to weed brownies. But some people love them.

What’s the truth? Are they good or bad? Spoiler alert: They’re great! Let’s get into the full review.